No democratic nation today acknowledges the use of torture, although some probably employ it as a necessary evil in certain scenarios should any modern democratic nation acknowledge the utility. Why torture is never justified there is never a time to use torture, never having been in the national security business and in international law for most of my career, i had not seen the. That said, the question remains could torture ever be justified there many who insist that the answer must be an emphatic 'no': that if we were to use torture, we would destroy any claim the.
If torture can prevent the imminent deaths then i would say it is probably justified click to expand the problem is that there's almost no way to know before hand whether or not the person you're torturing actually has what you need to know. During his state of the union address, president bush spoke about the horrifying torture techniques saddam hussein has inflicted on prisoners in iraq he described the use of electric shock. But in 1999, citing the slippery-slope argument, israel's supreme court ruled that torture could never be justified, even in the case of a ticking bomb it went on to outlaw techniques such as.
Use of torture is never justified essay 1876 words 8 pages pretend it's a regular tuesday morning going through the usual routine: waking up, taking a shower, eating breakfast, and then in the background, there's breaking news. Thirty-six percent of respondents, however, say that torture is rarely or never a justified interrogation method, with 21 percent saying rarely and 15 percent saying never partisanship. Torture is never justified -minded catholics a controversial article on catholic culture website on this current issue of the cia's use of torture to get. The problem is not just the definition of torture, but also that of unlawful combattant when there is a mass uprising, you are not supposed to treat all rebels as spies or illegal combatants.
Torture torture is justifiable the limited use of torture should be permitted in the us in order to protect the wellbeing of the public torture can be both an effective means of gathering information, and it can be reasonably justified in some circumstances. The ban on the use of torture is absolute under international law there are never exceptional circumstances that justify its use it is always morally repugnant and actually makes us less secure by weakening our moral authority and turning people against us. Torture is prohibited under federal law, as are lesser forms of detainee abuse such as cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment on his second day in office, president obama issued an executive order strengthening the ban on torture and limiting interrogators to the tactics in the army field manual.
Is the use torture ever justified according time in the follow asian, middle east and other countries have used torture as a tool of murder for over two thousand years. President bush has stated: torture is never acceptable, nor do we hand over people to countries that do torture michael scheuer, a former cia agent who claims to have started the rendition program, says that the main purpose of rendition is getting terrorists behind bars. Torture was the subject of the geneva convention as well as the convention against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment in signing these treaties, each nation made a commitment to take effective legislative, administrative, judicial or other measures to prevent acts of torture in any territory under its.
Use of torture is never justified essay 1876 words | 8 pages counter-terrorism efforts this is because prisoners will volunteer information, whether it is true or. First, torture is not clearly justified its use is hotly debated there seem to be two uses for torture: to extract information, or to threaten people using torture to extract information produces mixed results people lie just to end the torture they may not even have the information you're. But as previous polls have shown, when that kind of torture is connected to valuable information that prevents terrorism on american soil, it becomes the cost of doing business.
I do not believe torture is ever justifiable in the pursuit of information, nor is the use of torture for any political or judicial reason a legitimate policy there is a large scholarly body of evidence that indicates the use of torture does not elicit reliable information. For the definition of torture is ' the action or practice of inflicting severe pain on someone as a punishment or in order to force them to do or say something' that being said how can anyone have the right to carry out such an act, on another human, for whatever reason. Can torture ever be justified as part of the perspectives series, bbc religion and ethics asked two contributors to bbc one's religious debate programme the big questions to develop some of the. This only shows that the use of torture is primitive and its justification for national security is hypocrisy from those who preach the gospel of modernization moving on, amnesty international on august 2015 reported that over 300 protesters were apprehended and tortured in burundi.
The use of violence, whether by states or other groups, should be based on the same argument as that used to justify a declaration of war - just war theory. There is never a time to use torture, never having been in the national security business and in international law for most of my career, i had not seen the use of torture by the united states prior to september 2001. I will now present an argument for the use of torture in rare circumstances while many people have objected, on emotional grounds, to my defense of torture, no one has pointed out a flaw in my. Torture under normal circumstances does not seem to garner a lot of popular support but there is a commonly debated reasoning as to a justified use of torture the scenario is generally termed the ticking bomb situation (schweiker, 2008, santucci, 2008, hunsinger, 2008, kleinig, 2005, & bufacchi and arrigo, 2006.